Tufted vs. Quilted Mattresses: Which is Best for Comfort and Support?

What is a tufted mattress?

Tufting is a traditional method of keeping upholstery materials in the mattress in place. It is often distinguished by buttons or stitching that keep the fabric pulled into tight, cushioned squares. Tufts are an essential part of maintaining the mattresses’ shape and preventing them from collapsing. This design increases the longevity of your bed, making a tufted mattress a good investment. Most high-quality mattresses, including those from big brands such as Silentnight and Flaxby mattresses, are created with tufts.

However, tufts in lower-quality mattresses can be made from cheaper materials, making them more noticeable and sometimes uncomfortable to sleep on. This can be resolved with extra layers like a mattress protector or a cushioning mattress topper.

Types of mattresses that often feature tufting include:

• Pocket spring mattresses
• Hybrid mattresses
• Natural mattresses

What is a quilted mattress?

In contrast, a quilted mattress offers a smooth, flat sleeping surface with a plush, luxurious feel. It helps keep upholstery materials in place by stitching multiple layers of fabric and padding together. This quilting process secures the upholstery layers, such as foam and other soft materials, to the outer fabric or ticking (the top layer) of the mattress. The stitched patterns create pockets or channels, which prevent the fillings from shifting or bunching up over time.

Quilted mattresses are often crafted from a combination of natural and synthetic fibres. This helps to enhance breathability and helps regulate body temperature for a comfortable night’s sleep. These high-quality materials create a cosy, inviting feeling, making quilted mattresses visually appealing and ideal for those who prefer a smoother, cushioned surface. If you tend to overheat at night, explore our helpful tips for staying cool.

Common types of mattresses featuring quilted stitching include:

• Memory foam mattresses
• Pillow-top mattresses
• Hybrid mattresses
• Latex mattrresses

What is the difference between quilted and tufted mattresses?

Although quilted and tufted mattresses come in various firmness levels and materials, there are some key differences that can help you determine which would be best for you. Use the handy table below to compare their qualities:

Tufted mattresses	Quilted mattresses
Enhanced durability: Designed to prevent sagging and maintain shape over time.	Offers a flat feel: The quilted surface delivers a smooth, even sleeping area, making it easy to shift positions without feeling constrained.
Supportive: Ideal for back sleepers who prefer a firmer feel, offering excellent spinal alignment and support.	Soft surface: Ideal for those who enjoy a plush sleeping experience that gently cradles the body.
Provides a contoured feel: The tufting creates defined support zones, allowing the mattress to conform to your body’s natural curves for pressure relief.	Temperature regulation: Excellent for hot sleepers, thanks to breathable materials that promote airflow and keep you cool.

Another critical difference between the two is the price range. Tufted mattresses are typically more expensive due to the labour-intensive process involved in making them, and they are known for their durability. In contrast, quilted mattresses are generally more affordable, often using a more straightforward manufacturing process and polyester materials.

Whichever mattress you choose, explore our mattress care guide for helpful tips on keeping it clean and well-maintained. Remember, tufted and quilted mattresses offer unique benefits tailored to different sleep preferences.

What’s best: a tufted or quilted mattress?

A tufted mattress may be your best option for durability and reliable support from head to toe. A quilted mattress could be the ideal choice if you prefer a smooth surface that enhances comfort and temperature regulation. Ultimately, your decision should reflect your personal comfort needs and sleeping style. For more tips on selecting a new mattress, explore our guide: which mattress type is best for you.